Our Department is in the the process of purchesing an aerial ladder or plattform truck...... just wondering your thoughts or opinions on both or pro and cons on both.... thanks looking for your thoughts on both

Views: 1620

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

With a ladder you will get one ladder pipe master steam. A platform can have two master steams mounted to the platform.   

two would be a whole lot of water...lol

Are you replacing a ladder truck?

What do your mutual aid companies have?

What is your typical truck company need on the fire ground?  If you don't currently have a ladder, what fire ground need is driving the purchase?

 

Tower - Good working platform, excellent ability to deliver master streams, generally less compartment space (midmounts), bigger, heavier devices require bigger, heavier chassis and more maintenance costs.

 

 

 

yes we are replacing an old 1957 lafrance 65' arieal its sitting on a good mack chassis but the ladder wont pass inpections, we do have some tall buildins and house's in our area. the old ladder never had a pump on it so we are looking at one with one so we can possibly take an older pumper truck out and replace two trucks with one, there are only 2 ladder trucks in our county ours and one about 30 min away. we are hoping to help better with our mutal aid departments also with the new truck
If the 65' aerial working height is sufficient you may be able to combine apparatus on a 75' quint type rig. 

I would say you need to look at everything and weigh things out, seems like a few more options turned up on this thread moreso than just a straight stick or platform. One being the option of a quint with a 75' stick, which if the current ladder height sufficed now, may be your cheapest option ans still replace two rigs with one.

 

Although, it helps to look towards the future and try and plan ahead, especially with a long term purchase as a truck. Is a 65' really sufficient right now or would having a 100' be a better option? It sounds like you guys are also looking towards a quint to replace two rigs, so it comes down to that option too, you lose a lot of storage space with a quint as opposed to a truck, so if you are only the truck in the area for 30 minutes, can you afford to lose equipment that having a quint will do? Yet, if use is moreso for aerial streams, do you really want to tie up a pumper to supply water for a truck?

 

We currently have 2 platforms and one straight stick. The platform allows for a couple people in the bucket and can control operations from the tip. The platforms have multiple outlets for hose connections so the aerial can be used as a mobile standpipe, whereas the stick has one outlet. As mentioned there can be two master stream devices on a platform as opposed to one on a stick. The stick has a "rescue" and "water tower" lever that controls the water pipe, so you don't inadvertantly crush the waterway for a rescue, the platform, you don't have to worry about that since the ladder stays away from the building.

 

However, while we do use the platforms more, the straight stick still gives plenty of options at a lower cost than a platform. You can still accomplish many options with a stick like you can with a platform, it comes down to training and what you really want. Another thing you may want to look into is funding from other communities. If you are running MA or even automatic aid, with the ladder often, perhaps that is something to look into as well. The costs can be split to reduce the burden on your dept and other depts can benefit as well. This also gives you a chance to go with a better option that may be overlooked because of cost.

 

In the end, the platform gives a more stable option to operate from, you can have a couple FF's at the tip so a rescue isn't just on one FF, and also gives a second set of eyes. The platform can be more stable since they tend not to be affected as much by wind, etc, whereas a stick can bounce more. While a stick gives many of the same options on a limited basis, so it comes down to what you think works best for your dept and area. 

thanks for the iformation
You can have both

Another consideration is maneuverability.

 

A tractor drawn aerial beats mid-mounts, rear-mounts, and platforms for maneuverability hands down.

 

The trade-off is that it takes two drivers and the driver training requirements are more difficult and take longer if done right.

 Most manufactures will bring a demo to your dept. to try out for a day. You might look into this. Have a Platform brought then a stick.  A tiller is nice but they cost and there is the training as was mentioned.

  If your dept. doesn't do alot of truck work you might look at the platform. You really have to

be comfortable working off a stick, especialy at high angles. It can get tricky doin work off a stick plus getting a victem down is also tricky. 

  Like I said, try to get some demos brought to you and try them out in your area. Fly the ladder set up around your area. See what is going to work best for your dept.

 

Well the dission was made we will be purchacing a new sutphen 75' arieal quinte ladder i posted a picture of what its gonna look like
Attachments:
We use mostly tillers in DC and I love them.  However if you're not a mid to large city department, it might not be the best idea.  You always need a driver and a tiller man.  Many departments won't always be able to staff both positions, especially if its volunteer and you don't know who will show up.  You also probably don't even need them if it isn't a large city.  The roads are as tight or filled with cars.  When you do have the right staffing though, they are extremely quick to maneuver and can be set up much fast than a tower.

Reply to Discussion

RSS

FireRescue Magazine

Find Members Fast


Or Name, Dept, Keyword
Invite Your Friends
Not a Member? Join Now

© 2021   Created by Firefighter Nation WebChief.   Powered by

Badges  |  Contact Firefighter Nation  |  Terms of Service