Crash Site IC: “One of the Biggest, Hottest Fires I’ve Ever Seen”

I just spoke with Clarence Center Volunteer Fire Company (CCVFC) Chief Dave Case, who was the incident commander at the scene of the Continental commuter plane crash near Buffalo, N.Y. Despite it being difficult to digest everything that has happened in the past 12 hours, Case was able to offer FireRescue and some initial reflections on the event as well as a play by play of the response.

Case, who has been with the CCVFC for 17 years, was at home reading e-mails when he heard a loud “thud”: “It was a very weird noise so I got up to went to look out the window, thinking there had been some kind of bad car accident,” he says. “That's when the pager went off for a report of a plane into a house.”

En route to the incident, Case was expecting to find a single-engine Cessna—a two- or four-seater—but not a commuter plane. He met up with his first assistant, Tim Norris, who had been at the station, not far from the crash site, and immediately started putting together a game plan.

“Engine 2 was on location first with a full crew,” he explains. “We deployed large-diameter hose and secured a water source, which was a hydrant at the corner. Once we got water flowing on the structure, realizing the magnitude, we dropped back and protected the two closest exposures, which were about 20 feet from the wreckage.”

One of the first priorities was shutting off the natural gas. In an interesting twist, Case grew up on Long Street, about five houses from the crash site, and he used to work for a man who lived in the house where the plane crashed. “I knew that house well,” he says. “I thought I knew where the gas shut-off was, but it was long gone.” So they called in the local gas company to dig up the line and shut it off at the curb. It was impossible to access the gas meter due to the huge fire.

Case described the scene as something you’d see in a movie. “It was one of the biggest, hottest fires I’ve ever seen,” he says. “Flames were 50 to 60 feet in the air with heavy black smoke. You don’t think this is really happening in your town. Growing up on that street, you see planes come in and out, and you never expect something like this.”

Based on the volume of fire, it was immediately clear that there would not be survivors, Case says, so suppression was the major priority, along with protecting the exposures.

Considering the amount of jet fuel, he immediately called for the airport crash truck as well as all area fire companies under Amherst Fire to standby, and then started the incident command system. Additionally, Erie County Emergency Services started to show up and set up command. “We started our span of control from there,” he says. “I knew the EOC was set up by the Clarence Town Hall, and I knew my resources were being filled in that area.”

As for law enforcement, New York State Police and Erie County Sheriff’s Department set up a perimeter and cordoned off a two-block area. This perimeter was later expanded to a 2-mile radius.

Case says they received a report from airport that the plane was carrying approximately 3,500-5,000 gallons of fuel, which fueled the huge fire. “We made a very good effort to extinguish it,” he says. “We blackened it down in about 45 minutes to 1 hour. This gave us time for the airport crash truck to get there and start suppressing the flames with foam. That really darkened the fire down.” He adds that crews have been extinguishing hot spots throughout the day in order to cool off the scene for the NTSB.

Case was on scene for about 12 hours before he relinquished command to Assistant Chief Tim Norris.

As for lessons learned, Case offers this: “I need some more time to digest everything that has happened but one thing is you must always be prepared for the worst. Don’t think it can’t happen to you? It will.”

Case adds: “To all who responded, I want to say thank you as an officer and as a friend. Everyone here did a fantastic job. The span of control was flawless. There was no freelancing. The scene was secure. We went in and did our jobs to the best of our abilities. I am super proud of the responders.”

For more on the crash, check out my earlier interview with another first responder, as well as FirefighterNation’s continuing coverage.

Janelle Foskett is senior editor of FireRescue magazine.

Views: 187

Add a Comment

You need to be a member of My Firefighter Nation to add comments!

Join My Firefighter Nation

Comment by Roy Walker on February 19, 2009 at 12:40am
Well done gentlemen well done . This is the call we all fear and hope will never come. Now we should all hope that if and when it does we respond as well as you and your crews did. We are proud to call you brothers and rest assured that all behaved in the finest traditions of the fire service.
Comment by Al on February 18, 2009 at 1:52pm
Just a quick Well Done to all Fire, Rescue , Ambulance ,Police, Amherst Dispatch..and any one who assisted at the incident and the past 5 days... Airport Fire Crash rescue needed all the assistance and cooperation that was recieved.

and A Big Good Job for the Clarence Center helping Cambria in their time of need with a truck catching on fire in the Hall......
Comment by Tiger Schmittendorf on February 16, 2009 at 10:40pm
I'm not sure I've ever been prouder of a group of people than I am of the men and women of the Clarence Center Volunteer Fire Company and all their mutual aid partners right now.

As Deputy Fire Coordinator for Erie County and as the Incident Commander in the EOC, I am not in the least surprised by their actions, their professionalism, their respect and their caring for all those affected. I would expect nothing else. I am simply in awe.

I've known all along that we have some of the greatest firefighters right here in Erie County. Chief Dave Case and his entire team have just proven it to the rest of the world.

I was there with them from the onset and we will be together until the end of this operation and beyond. I am proud and honored to stand amongst them and to call them my friends.

I thank them for their service.
Comment by Todd Bane on February 16, 2009 at 11:40am
Having had the ability to go up and see the scene and talk with Chief Case and Chief Norris, an unbelievable job was done protecting the exposures. The crash area was very small but the houses very close on either side. Fantastic job done and I hope this incident has no long no lasting negative effects on your members. Thank you for taking the time to walk myself and my firefighter around your scene. I learned a great deal.
Comment by Glen Garland on February 14, 2009 at 6:38pm
Chief, Kudos to you and all the crews that responded. Our thoughts and prayers are with you, all the responders, and the families of the crash victims. Take care and remember that sometimes our best efforts can't change the outcome. Take care and God Bless
Comment by Jeff Ripley on February 14, 2009 at 3:15pm
Good job, Chief. I know the outcome is never good in these incidents, I take my Captain's hat off to you for your expertise on scene, strong initial decision making, and your compliments to your immediate and surrounding crews. They're the folks who get it done on the ground and I never try to lose sight of that.
Comment by Trevor Wendt on February 14, 2009 at 12:48pm
Our thoughts and prayers are with you guys! Thank you!

Cambria Vol. Fire Co.
Niagara County, New York
Comment by Dave, NB 9 on February 14, 2009 at 9:35am

This is from the area news paper.
Comment by Dave, NB 9 on February 14, 2009 at 9:24am
listen to a recording of dispatch,go to
Comment by William Reinhard on February 14, 2009 at 8:31am
Great job!....My prayer go out to the family and to all the responders....

FireRescue Magazine

Find Members Fast

Or Name, Dept, Keyword
Invite Your Friends
Not a Member? Join Now

© 2020   Created by Firefighter Nation WebChief.   Powered by

Badges  |  Contact Firefighter Nation  |  Terms of Service